.avif)
Fully custom wedding cakes baked from scratch, designed around your vision. From intimate gatherings to grand celebrations, we make cakes that taste as beautiful as they look.
Your flavours, chosen from our scratch-made menu
Your design, built around your vision
Your details, down to the last finish
Four steps and you're done — we handle the rest
Browse our flavours, fillings, and design options below to get an idea of how we can work together.
Fill out our inquiry form with your date, guest count, and any inspiration you have. We'll confirm availability and reach out within 2 business days.
We finalize your design and hold your date with a deposit. You'll receive a full written quote before anything is locked in.
We deliver (and set up for weddings.) Enjoy your custom made cake and the love it conveys.
Investment
Intimate
From
$150
Serves 20–40 guests · 1 tier
Your choice of standard flavours & filling
Simple buttercream finish
Heart or round shape
Instructions on how to save slices for your anniversary included
Delivery available
Classic
From
$225
Serves 50–80 guests · 2 tiers
Your choice of premium flavours & fillings
Ornate buttercream finish
Heart or round shape
Instructions on how to save slices for your anniversary included
Delivery & set up at the venue
Grand
From
Custom
Serves 20+ guests · 1-3 tiers
Multiple flavour & filling combinations
Intricate designs, fresh florals
Custom shapes including table runner
Personalized design process
Delivery & set up at the venue
Extra
From
$5 per guest
Extra sweeteness for your guests to enjoy
Cupcakes for a classic after dinner treat
Cake cups for elevated desserts for your guests
Sweet charcuterie spreads for grazing
Brownie bar for guests to create their own sweets
Cookies for late night pick-me-ups
Design & Finish
Fresh florals, palette knife flowers, or hand-piped botanical details.
Rustic lines, semi-naked finishes, subtle textures. For couples who want elegance without excess.
With shell borders and extra piping details, these cakes can range from simple to over the top.
Mix and match by tier — because variety is the whole point
Tiramisu
PS Bakery's take on tiramisu with vanilla bean sponge, coffee soak, creamy filling and cocoa powder
Chocolate
Hands down the best chocolate cake you'll ever have
Carrot Cake
Warm spices, real carrots, a fan favourite
London Fog
Bergamot-infused, subtle and refined
Lemon Elderflower
Lemon cake, elderflower soak, lemon curd, and subtle elderflower Swiss meringue buttercream
Chocolate Fudge
Fudgey, slightly tangy chocolate frosting. Nostalgic and delicious.
Vanilla Bean
Classic and clean, pairs with everything
Dark Chocolate Ganache
Smooth dark chocolate ganache with a hint of espresso
Salted Caramel
A crowd-pleaser, every time
Strawberry Compote
Strawberry goodness all year round
Lemon Curd
Bright lemon flavour, silky smooth texture
Cream Cheese Frosting
Tangy and smooth. Essential with carrot cake
Whipped White Chocolate Ganache
Rich flavour, light texture, packed with vanilla bean
Swiss Meringue Buttercream
Silky, light, not too sweet; our standard buttercream
We take a limited number of wedding bookings per season to make sure every cake gets the time it deserves. We recommend reaching out at least 6–8 weeks before your date, and earlier for summer and fall weekends. Popular dates (May–October) often book out 3–4 months in advance.
Made-to-order cakes for your event
Design consultations with our expert bakers
Delivery and setup for seamless service
Kind Words
Real reviews from weddings, birthdays, markets, and every celebration in between.
"Liz made our wedding cake, and it was absolutely perfect! The carrot cake was a huge hit with all our guests - so delicious and beautifully done. Highly recommend!"
"Ordered cupcakes for my daughter’s wedding. The presentation and creativity was exactly what we were looking for. Exceeded my expectations actually. The taste and moistness of the cupcakes and the buttery icing was incredible. Liz was easy to work with and delivered to the venue as planned"
"Had one of their cinnamon buns at a local market and it was the best I’ve had in decades! So good with or without the delicious chilled cream cheese icing and served with a smile! Sorry there are no photos since it was too tasty and disappeared fast!"
"PS Bakery has the BEST cinnamon buns (or “Cinnies”)! Liz (the baker) has a stand at the Sunday Thornbury Farmers Market and also bakes custom orders. Contact her by email to order. I made sure to order extra for the freezer and they came packed in oven-ready trays for reheating. An all around great experience!"
"Delicious !!! I recently ordered a cake for Valentines Day and was impressed by the presentation, most importantly - the taste and professionalism. Thanks Liz, I’ll definitely be ordering again!"
"We bought cookies and a gingerbread man decorating kit at the Christmas market. Everything was delicious and reasonably priced!"
Everything you need to know about ordering from P.S. Bakery.
We recommend booking at least 6–8 weeks before your wedding date. Summer and fall Saturdays fill up 3–4 months ahead. The earlier, the better.
We deliver and set up wedding cakes throughout Collingwood, Wasaga Beach, and the Georgian Bay. Venue delivery fees vary by distance. Pickup is also available.
We require a 20% deposit to hold your date, with the balance due two weeks before your wedding. We accept e-transfer and credit card.
Yes, there are a limited number of standard cakes released every week. Options include 4” Bento cakes, 6” double chocolate and double vanilla bean cakes, and our famous cinnamon buns in packs of 4. Ordering opens on Tuesday mornings weekly and goes until Friday morning or sold out. Pick up on Saturdays.
This form is for custom cake orders. We are closed on Sundays and Mondays. Please provide as much detail as possible. There will be a follow-up email within 2-3 business days.