Custom Cakes

Mix and match flavours and styles to create a cake perfectly tailored to your celebration.

Explore our creations

Discover our custom cake designs

image of wedding cake design
image of dessert selection (for a fine dining restaurant)
image of themed event decorations (for a bakery)
image of detailed cake selections (for a bakery)
image of assorted baked goods

Customer Kind Words

What people are saying

Real reviews from weddings, birthdays, markets, and every celebration in between.

"Liz made our wedding cake, and it was absolutely perfect! The carrot cake was a huge hit with all our guests - so delicious and beautifully done. Highly recommend!"

Ryleigh L.
Happy Bride

"Ordered cupcakes for my daughter’s wedding. The presentation and creativity was exactly what we were looking for. Exceeded my expectations actually. The taste and moistness of the cupcakes and the buttery icing was incredible. Liz was easy to work with and delivered to the venue as planned"

Kim K.
Mother of the Bride

"Had one of their cinnamon buns at a local market and it was the best I’ve had in decades! So good with or without the delicious chilled cream cheese icing and served with a smile! Sorry there are no photos since it was too tasty and disappeared fast!"

Sandra N.
Cinnamon Bun Lover

"PS Bakery has the BEST cinnamon buns (or “Cinnies”)! Liz (the baker) has a stand at the Sunday Thornbury Farmers Market and also bakes custom orders. Contact her by email to order. I made sure to order extra for the freezer and they came packed in oven-ready trays for reheating. An all around great experience!"

Rob C.
Longtime Customer

"Delicious !!! I recently ordered a cake for Valentines Day and was impressed by the presentation, most importantly - the taste and professionalism. Thanks Liz, I’ll definitely be ordering again!"

Ashley M.
A Perfect Valentine

I ordered a custom cake from PS Bakery for my son’s 5th birthday and it was absolutely delicious! Very moist and perfectly sweet! He was thrilled with the design and the guests enjoyed it as well! Thank you, Liz!

Janessa M.
Happy Customer

Custom cakes, crafted for your event

Good questions, straight answers

Everything you need to know about ordering from PS Bakery.

How do I place a custom order?

Fill out our Custom Cake Order Form with your event date, cake size, and any flavour or design ideas. We'll get back to you within two business days with options and pricing.

How much notice do you need?

Two weeks or more is ideal for custom cakes, and the minimum is three days. Wedding cakes need at least three weeks, and the more notice the better.

Do you offer tastings?

Tasting appointments aren't something we offer, but you can order a tasting box: a curated selection of cupcakes to sample flavours before you commit.

Do you have standard cakes?

Yes, a limited number of standard cakes and bakes are released every week, like The Classics, Henderson Double Chocolate, and our famous brioche cinnamon buns. Everything currently available is listed on the menu page.

Custom Cake Order Form

This form is for custom cake orders. We are closed on Sundays and Mondays. Please provide as much detail as possible. There will be a follow-up email within two business days.

What is the occasion?

Design preference (select all that apply)

Flavour preferences

Cake
Icing
Fillings (optional)

Thank you! We've received your request and will be in touch within two business days.

Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.